大陸的信收不到

[alex]

救命阿~
為什麼我架設的時候,有些地方寄過來沒有問題,但有的就是寄不過來,會被退信,
就拿這個來說吧,這是大陸的一個 163.com 從來沒有成功過,why
MX記錄正常 napopwin.com.tw
是什麼原因阿~


''################ 退信內容 ##########################
This is the Postfix program at host mta248.163.com.

I''m sorry to have to inform you that the message returned
below could not be delivered to one or more destinations.

For further assistance, please contact <postmaster@163.com>

If you do so, please include this problem report. You can
delete your own text from the message returned below.

The Postfix program

亲爱的网易邮箱用户:
抱歉的通知您,您的邮件无法投递到目的地址.
下面是系统返回的错误原因(例如:收件人地址不正确,信箱满或此信被对方拒收).
必要时您可跟对方或对方管理员联系.
网易邮件事业部

<napopwin@napopwin.com.tw>: Name service error for domain napopwin.com.tw: Host
found but no data record of requested type
''##########################################################

[csz]

大陸這個地方很奇怪!去年他們在開全代會時,在大陸的一些分公司透過
internet回台灣收發郵件就是時好時壞, 壞的時候會連不上mail server,
可是server明明沒問題, 那15天我被罵的臭頭!

[Arnor]

假設163.com 用的dns server 不像我們用的 dns.hinet.net 一樣好的話, 有可能的.

我做了個小實驗.
Default Server: dns.hinet.net
Address: 168.95.1.1

> set q=mx
> napopwin.com.tw
Server: dns.hinet.net
Address: 168.95.1.1

napopwin.com.tw MX preference = 10, mail exchanger = napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218
> set q=all
> napopwin.com.tw
Server: dns.hinet.net
Address: 168.95.1.1

Non-authoritative answer:
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = www.napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = napopwin.com.tw

napopwin.com.tw nameserver = www.napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = napopwin.com.tw
www.napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218
napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218

以dns.hinet.net 來查 napopwin.com.tw, 結果還好..
不過我覺得若能補上上面紅色的資料會不會更好?

繼續假設163.com 用的dns server 是用他們自己的.
> 163.com
Server: dns.hinet.net
Address: 168.95.1.1

Non-authoritative answer:
163.com internet address = 202.106.185.77
163.com nameserver = NS.NEASE.NET
163.com nameserver = NS2.NEASE.NET
163.com
primary name server = ns.163.com
responsible mail addr = admin.NEASE.NET
serial = 20010356
refresh = 10800 (3 hours)
retry = 3600 (1 hour)
expire = 360000 (4 days 4 hours)
default TTL = 3600 (1 hour)
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m210.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m180.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m183.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m207.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m208.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m209.163.com

163.com nameserver = NS.NEASE.NET
163.com nameserver = NS2.NEASE.NET
NS.NEASE.NET internet address = 202.106.185.75
NS2.NEASE.NET internet address = 61.145.113.57
m210.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.210
m180.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.180
m183.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.183
m207.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.207
m208.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.208
m209.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.209

我猜他們的dns server 應該是 202.106.185.75 和 61.145.113.57
202.106.185.75 查起來怪怪的, 換成 61.145.113.57 查之後,
蠻正常的, 如下:
> server 61.145.113.57
Default Server: [61.145.113.57]
Address: 61.145.113.57

> set q=all
> 163.com
Server: [61.145.113.57]
Address: 61.145.113.57

163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m207.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m208.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m209.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m210.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m180.163.com
163.com MX preference = 50, mail exchanger = m183.163.com
163.com internet address = 202.106.185.77
163.com nameserver = ns.nease.net
163.com nameserver = ns2.nease.net
163.com
primary name server = ns.163.com
responsible mail addr = admin.nease.net
serial = 20010356
refresh = 10800 (3 hours)
retry = 3600 (1 hour)
expire = 360000 (4 days 4 hours)
default TTL = 3600 (1 hour)
163.com nameserver = ns.nease.net
163.com nameserver = ns2.nease.net
m207.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.207
m208.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.208
m209.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.209
m210.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.210
m180.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.180
m183.163.com internet address = 202.108.44.183
ns.nease.net internet address = 202.106.185.75
ns2.nease.net internet address = 61.145.113.57
>

換成查 napopwin.com.tw , 你看變成什麼了..

> napopwin.com.tw
Server: [61.145.113.57]
Address: 61.145.113.57

Non-authoritative answer:
napopwin.com.tw MX preference = 10, mail exchanger = napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw
primary name server = nserver
responsible mail addr = administrator
serial = 4
refresh = 900 (15 mins)
retry = 600 (10 mins)
expire = 86400 (1 day)
default TTL = 3600 (1 hour)
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = nserver

napopwin.com.tw nameserver = nserver
>

這兩行頗怪........難怪它的原因是說
Name service error for domain napopwin.com.tw: Host
found but no data record of requested type

會是這原因嗎? 跟用dns.hinet.net 查的結果果然是不同的..
> napopwin.com.tw
Server: dns.hinet.net
Address: 168.95.1.1

Non-authoritative answer:
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = www.napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = napopwin.com.tw

napopwin.com.tw nameserver = www.napopwin.com.tw
napopwin.com.tw nameserver = napopwin.com.tw
www.napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218
napopwin.com.tw internet address = 211.20.143.218

若真的他們用的是這個dns server ....會是問題嗎?
_________________
*若是想問問題的話, 請務必不要塗改任何 IP, 網域資料, 您若不願貼上IP或網域, 請改以電子郵件來詢問. 謝謝您的配合.*
*若是回報疑似軟體的運行或邏輯或資料處理有誤的問題, 小弟很樂意去了解您的情況, 但請務必以最新版來做回報, 如果以郵件詢問, 請參考 http://www.raidenmaild.com/tw/feedback.html 的說明, 最好標題加個 RaidenMAILD 字樣, 才不致會遺漏了您的信唷. 謝謝您的配合^^*
*在版上發文請遵守網路禮儀, 並請持著虛心敘述問題請教他人, 凡發現違反的文, 均一律刪除為優先, 不另行通知喔.
*與使用者教學相長腦力激盪是我輩成就感的來源, 誠心希望您能不吝指教.
*雷電MAILD 知識庫文件 http://www.raidenmaild.com/tw/kb/

素還尊
Team John Long.
Email: arnor@raidenmaild.com
公司網站 http://www.raidenmaild.com/company/

[alex]

我按照大大的方式去查了,果然是很奇怪,後來163.com還是寄不進去,但他們大陸的公司就可以了,所以我想說163.com那個就算了,
還有,原先他們大陸公司的信收不到的時候,server有架AD ,後來我重裝了2000,就沒裝AD,之後就可以收到了,不曉得是不是跟AD有關,再次請教您~

[commer]

因該無關吧!!只要他們的dns指向的mail server ok!就沒問題阿!!
可能taiwan的某些ip被ban掉了吧???